All-Inclusive vs Self-Catering Holidays

When planning a holiday, one of the biggest decisions is the type of holiday package you choose. Should you book an all-inclusive resort where almost everything is covered, or opt for self-catering and enjoy complete freedom to roam around, explore and dine as and when and where you please? In this post we look at All-Inclusive vs Self-Catering Holidays.

All-Inclusive vs Self-Catering Holidays

All-Inclusive vs Self-Catering Holidays

There isn’t a single right answer. The best choice depends on your budget, travel style, who you’re travelling with and what you want from your holiday.

While many people assume all-inclusive holidays always offer better value, that isn’t necessarily true. Likewise, self-catering isn’t always the cheapest option once you factor in meals, drinks and entertainment.

This guide compares both holiday styles, helping you decide which one gives you the best value for your next getaway.

What Is an All-Inclusive Holiday?

An all-inclusive holiday usually includes:

Accommodation

Breakfast, lunch and dinner

Snacks

Soft drinks

Local alcoholic drinks

Entertainment

Swimming pools

Children’s clubs

Many on-site activities

Some will also include transfers, carry on bags and checked bags.

Although packages vary between hotels, the aim is simple: pay upfront and worry less about spending while you’re away.

What Is a Self-Catering Holiday?

A self-catering holiday provides accommodation with cooking facilities.

Depending on the property, you’ll normally have access to:

A kitchen

Fridge

Cooker

Microwave

Dining area

Food and drinks are not included, allowing you to decide where and when you eat each day.

Pin It!

All-Inclusive vs Self-Catering Holidays

Why Choose an All-Inclusive Holiday?

For many travellers, convenience is the biggest selling point.

Everything is available in one place, making holidays far more relaxing. Families especially appreciate unlimited drinks, snacks and entertainment without constantly reaching for their wallet.

Benefits include:

Predictable holiday costs

Unlimited meals

On-site entertainment

Family-friendly facilities

Less planning during your trip

Excellent value if you spend most of your time at the resort

Why Choose Self-Catering?

Self-catering offers complete flexibility.

Rather than eating at the hotel every day, you can discover local cafés, markets and restaurants while experiencing the destination more like a local.

Many travellers enjoy the freedom to create their own schedule.

Benefits include:

Greater flexibility

Freedom to explore

Access to local cuisine

Potential savings if you cook occasionally

Better for longer stays

Ideal for independent travellers

Cost Comparison

Many people assume self-catering automatically costs less.

However, daily expenses can quickly increase when you add:

Breakfast

Lunch

Evening meals

Drinks

Snacks

Ice creams

Cocktails

In popular tourist destinations, restaurant prices can be much higher than expected.

If you eat out three times a day, an all-inclusive package may actually cost less overall.

Pin It!

All-Inclusive vs Self-Catering Holidays

Which Option Is Better for Families?

For families with young children, all-inclusive holidays usually provide better value.

Children often want:

Drinks throughout the day

Ice cream

Snacks

Entertainment

Swimming pools

Having everything included reduces stress and helps parents stick to their holiday budget.

Self-catering can still work well for larger families, particularly if accommodation includes a full kitchen and nearby supermarkets.

Which Is Better for Couples?

The answer depends on the type of holiday.

Couples looking for total relaxation often enjoy adult only all-inclusive resorts with spa facilities, beach bars and evening entertainment.

However, couples who enjoy discovering hidden restaurants, local culture and day trips usually prefer self-catering or bed and breakfast accommodation.

Destination Matters

The destination can influence which option offers the best value.

Spain

Spain has fantastic restaurants, tapas bars and cafés, making self-catering an attractive option for food lovers. However, there are plenty of wonderful all-inclusive beach resorts in Spain that are ideal for those with children.

Dominican Republic

Many visitors rarely leave their resort because the hotels include excellent restaurants, beaches and activities. All-inclusive often delivers exceptional value here.

Turkey

Turkey is famous for affordable luxury resorts, making all-inclusive one of the best-value holiday choices available.

Greece

If you’re planning to explore several villages and beaches, self-catering offers greater flexibility.

Mexico

Luxury all-inclusive resorts dominate many beach destinations, making them ideal for travellers who want everything included.

Pin It!

All-Inclusive vs Self-Catering Holidays

Questions to Ask Before Booking

Before deciding, ask yourself:

Will I spend most of my time at the hotel?

Do I enjoy trying local restaurants?

Am I travelling with children?

Do I want to stick to a fixed budget?

Will I hire a car?

Do I prefer relaxing or exploring?

Your answers will quickly reveal which holiday style suits you best.

Which Holiday Offers Better Value?

Neither option wins every time.

Choose all-inclusive if you:

Want convenience

Like relaxing at the resort

Travel with children

Enjoy unlimited food and drinks

Prefer knowing your costs before travelling

Choose self-catering if you:

Love exploring

Enjoy local restaurants

Want complete flexibility

Plan day trips every day

Prefer cooking occasionally to save money

Pin It!

All-Inclusive vs Self-Catering Holidays

Final Verdict

Both all-inclusive and self-catering holidays can offer excellent value, but only when they match your travel style.

If your dream holiday involves lazy days by the pool, unlimited food, evening entertainment and a fixed budget, an all-inclusive package is difficult to beat.

If, however, you enjoy discovering local culture, trying independent restaurants and creating your own itinerary, self-catering could provide a richer and more flexible experience.

Instead of asking which option is better, ask which one fits the holiday you want to have. That simple question will help you choose the package that offers the best value—and the best memories.

What Do You Think?

Considering everything you have just read in my post All-Inclusive vs Self-Catering Holidays, would you choose an all-inclusive holiday or self-catering for your next trip? Tell me why in the comments below. I would love to hear your experiences and recommendations.

Other Posts You Might Like:

Holiday Beauty Essentials: What You Really Need to Pack

Are All-Inclusive Holidays Worth the Money?

Tips for Planning a Multi-Generational Holiday This Summer

Five Active Holidays for Older Folk

Different Types of European Beach Club Holidays

Plan Your Group Ski Holiday

The Top Italian Lake Holiday Destinations

6 Types of Holidays to Experience in Croatia

Holiday Essentials For A First Trip Abroad

Enjoyed this Post?

Subscribe to Melanie’s Fab Finds RSS feed to see my latest posts. Posts will include recipes, reviews, etc. and as a result, you will hear about my new posts and competitions first!

Watch our fab product reviews on YouTube x


Discover more from Melanie's Fab Finds

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

This Post Has 44 Comments

  1. Beth

    I think I would probably go with an all-inclusive trip just for ease, but I love seeing the comparison of the two.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      They can make taking a trip much easier and are ideal for a relaxed break.

  2. Ben

    I feel like I would go with the self-catering option. I like the freedom, and I enjoy keeping things simple.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      Self -catering can work well. You can eat out when you don’t want to cook and explore a wider range of restaurants and dishes.

  3. Amber Myers

    I have done both. I prefer all inclusive just because it’s nice to have the budget already there. Plus it’s easier to plan. But a self-catering can be an adventure as well.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      Both can make for great holidays which is good although all-inclusives can be often more cost effective.

  4. Richard Lowe

    I usually do self-catering but I can see how all inclusive would be advantageous Next time I go on a holiday or vacation I’ll look at this article again.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      All-inclusive can be so much more relaxed which is why I personally love them x

  5. Jen

    I’ve always wanted to stay at an all-inclusive resort! The only thing somewhat close to it is when we went on a cruise. I’d like to visit an all-inclusive beach resort in Spain!

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      There are many options for you too choose from in Spain which can help. There are also different types of all-inclusive!

  6. Asha C

    In the past we have always gone for self-catering as it seemed like the cheaper option to buy and cook our own food. Now I am that bit older I am leaning more towards all-inclusive as there seem to be lots of perks!

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      There sure are and it’s great if you have kids that are hungry all the time!!!!

  7. Marie Cris Angeles

    This is perfect timing. I am planning a family vacation for this coming October. My sister’s birthday and reading this helped me a lot.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      I’m so glad to hear that. Hope you all have a wonderful time x

  8. jerryj@g.com

    I have been to more than 15 all-inclusive holidays in Mexico, Cuba, and the DR. Your comparison of all-inclusive and self-catering holidays highlights an important choice every traveler faces. I love how you show that the best option depends on personal style, from relaxing convenience to exploring local culture and cuisine.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      They can vary depending on location so you need to have a clear idea of what you are after and look into each. I bet you had some wonderful experiences x

  9. Carol Cassara

    What a comprehensive set of comparisons! We’ve taken both kinds of trips and still go between the two. Both kinds of vacations have their positives but I think you cover all the factors people need to consider as they plan a trip.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      It’s all dependent on personal preference and what we want from a holiday.

  10. LisaLisa

    I think there really isn’t a one size fits all answer because it depends on the type of holiday you’re looking for. I love the convenience of an all-inclusive trip when I just want to relax and not think about cooking, but self-catering is perfect when you want to explore local restaurants and experience the destination more like a local. You did a wonderful job highlighting the pros of both options,

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      That’s very true, but all-inclusives vary and you can tailor self-catering breaks to your needs. The great thing is we are spoilt for choice.

  11. Stephanie

    Most of the time, my family does a self-catering vacation. With 4 people, the cost of an all-inclusive can be prohibitive for us. I also like the flexibility it offers. But, my husband and I went to an all-inclusive for our honeymoon, and it was great to not have to worry about anything!

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      It is lovely not to have to think about having to find somewhere to eat or what foods people will eat. The all-inclusives have a wonderful selection.

  12. Karen

    We always opt for self catering because we feel we get to enjoy more of the local culture and more opportunities to interact with locals. That said, all inclusive has its amazing advantages as well.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      Self-catering works well for many – you can always have brunch and an evening meal out to make it easier

  13. Alejandra

    I’m an all-inclusive kind of girl. Self-catering can be useful sometimes, but I feel that if I’m on holiday, I want to stay away from the kitchen lol

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      Me too, it’s so much more relaxed x

  14. Jupiter Hadley

    I do love all inclusives, especially as I have gotten older and my children have gotten older. There is a lot to be said about self catering as well!

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      Both can be great depending on the type of break you are after

  15. Clarice

    I actually prefer all-inclusive holidays whenever possible because they make it so much easier to stick to a budget. Since most things are already included, there’s less temptation to overspend. I’m also not a fan of self-catering. When I’m on vacation, I want a real break, and that includes taking a break from cooking too!

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      It can be a great way to control how much is spent on a trip.

  16. Mahy

    I always think I will cook on holiday, then realise breakfast shopping can become an unwanted chore. Just a note from my life LOL

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      All-inclusives can be so much easier and you have a wide range of options.

  17. Barbie R

    I love all-inclusive resorts because they make traveling so much easier. You do not have to worry about planning every little thing or constantly reaching for your wallet. Everything you need is right there, so you can relax and enjoy the trip.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      I completely agree, they really do allow you to relax much more than self-catering.

  18. Haridas s

    I’ll be opting for a self-catering holiday because like Ben said, the freedom to choose what I want is critical. Thank you very much for educating me about this.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      Self-catering can work well and can be a good way to explore the place you have visited without ties.

  19. Jenny

    We’ve never tried an all inclusive holiday. Self catering works perfectly for us and the way we like to enjoy our holidays.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      All-Inc isn’t for for everyone. Self-catering works well for many too x

  20. Elizabeth F

    While I do appreciate the benefits of the self catering option, I’m all in for an all inclusive vacation trip. I know that, for people with special dietary needs, the self catering option could be a life saver. I just want to go away and step out of the kitchen for a restful vacation and not deal with shopping, prepping and cooking.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      Some places now cater for those with specific dietary needs making all-inclusive far more inclusive than ever!

  21. Khushboo

    I would love all inclusive trip and self catering trip. Both have its own fun. I just want a trip it doesn’t matter any of them.

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      Ha, I know what you mean, any is better than nothing xxx

  22. Laura

    I find I like somewhere in the middle! I def dont want to cook my own meal on holiday. But I also don’t want to feel that I need to eat every meal on property. I like to mix it up!!

    1. Melanie Edjourian

      It can be nice to mix it up but then don’t forget some all-inclusives have a variety of on-site restaurants.

Leave a Reply